Sex Ratio misconception. Kerala is as worse as Gujarat

As the run up to 2014 continues, there are people out there dismissing Narendra Modi ‘with facts’. One such parameter in the rankings widely circulated is sex ratio and would look like

Sex ratio Kerala 1 Gujarat 24

Anyone who just reads headlines, doesn’t go into detail will simply buy the argument. But lets look at Sex ratio data. First up is the data represented in way most people do. From Wikipedia article on Indian states and territories ranked by sex ratio

Sex ratio Kerala 1084 Gujarat 918 TamilNadu 995

What is wrong in it? It has an inherent bias to female. As per Fisher’s principle, the equillibrium sex ratio for any species is 1:1. So reordering the list with closeness to 1000 Kerala ranks 25, while Gujarat ranks 23. Tamil Nadu ranks 1.

So next time someone gets sex ratio argument, tell them Kerala is as worse as Gujarat (slightly more worse in absolute numbers).

Skewed interpretation of data leads to screwed policies. If there is any state in India which badly needs to have a Ministry for men welfare and development, it is Kerala going by feminists logic.

No one denies female foeticide / infanticide are evils which needs to be eradicated. But just because the sex ratio isn’t perfectly 1:1 doesn’t mean the society is regressive and women need more/special privileges to increase the number to make the society perfectly Fisherian. Fact is nothing can change what nature wishes. 1000:900 / 1000:1100 is perfectly okay sex ratio to have and it will automatically balance itself if not for infanticide. In India 1000:900 will work best until older men marry younger women as they will be borrowing females from future. If the ratio reverses, women will have to marry younger men or marry outside the region. Will a Congress PM / anyone other than Narendra Modi as PM automagically change the sex ratio? Have they done it in the past? Then why is it even a factor?

Tables of sex ratio in both sort order.

Ranking State Sex ratio
1 Kerala 1084
2 Puducherry 1031
3 Tamil Nadu 995
4 Andhra Pradesh 992
5 Chattisgarh 991
6 Manipur 987
7 Meghalaya 986
8 Odisha 978
9 Mizoram 975
10 Himachal Pradesh 974
11 Karnataka 968
12 Goa 968
13 Uttarakhand 963
14 Tripura 961
15 Assam 954
16 Lakshadweep 946
17 Jharkhand 947
18 West Bengal 947
19 Maharashtra 946
** INDIA 940
20 Nagaland 931
21 Madhya Pradesh 930
22 Rajasthan 926
23 Arunachal Pradesh 920
24 Gujarat 918
25 Bihar 916
26 Uttar Pradesh 908
27 Punjab 893
28 Sikkim 889
29 Jammu & Kashmir 883
30 Andaman & Nicobar Islands 878
31 Haryana 877
32 Delhi 866
33 Chandigarh 818
34 Dadra & Nagar Haveli 775
35 Daman & Diu 618

Reordering with closeness to 1000.

Ranking State Sex Ratio Distance from Perfection Absolute distance
1 Tamil Nadu 995 -5 5
2 Andhra Pradesh 992 -8 8
3 Chattisgarh 991 -9 9
4 Manipur 987 -13 13
5 Meghalaya 986 -14 14
6 Odisha 978 -22 22
7 Mizoram 975 -25 25
8 Himachal Pradesh 974 -26 26
9 Puducherry 1031 31 31
10 Karnataka 968 -32 32
11 Goa 968 -32 32
12 Uttarakhand 963 -37 37
13 Tripura 961 -39 39
14 Assam 954 -46 46
15 Jharkhand 947 -53 53
16 West Bengal 947 -53 53
17 Lakshadweep 946 -54 54
18 Maharashtra 946 -54 54
** INDIA 940 -60 60
19 Nagaland 931 -69 69
20 Madhya Pradesh 930 -70 70
21 Rajasthan 926 -74 74
22 Arunachal Pradesh 920 -80 80
23 Gujarat 918 -82 82
24 Bihar 916 -84 84
25 Kerala 1084 84 84
26 Uttar Pradesh 908 -92 92
27 Punjab 893 -107 107
28 Sikkim 889 -111 111
29 Jammu & Kashmir 883 -117 117
30 Andaman & Nicobar Islands 878 -122 122
31 Haryana 877 -123 123
32 Delhi 866 -134 134
33 Chandigarh 818 -182 182
34 Dadra & Nagar Haveli 775 -225 225
35 Daman & Diu 618 -382 382
Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Sex Ratio misconception. Kerala is as worse as Gujarat

  1. Sixer

    Will a Congress PM / anyone other than Narendra Modi as PM automagically change the sex ratio? Have they done it in the past? Then why is it even a factor?

    Will Congress PM / anyone other than Narendra Modi as PM automagically change the corruption? Have they done it in the past? Then why is it even a factor?

    Just vote for Congress . . .

    Reply
    1. sundakka Post author

      If don’t even know if there is an attempted sarcasm in your comment. But if you have anything to add on sexratio, please do, else get the f off from here.

      Reply
  2. poovannan73

    The 0-6 sex ratio indicates the amount of female foeticide better.kerala has 959 females per 1000 male,TN 946 and gujarat 886.Even within gujarat the 886 is due to better child sex ratio of muslims and tribals and the core BJP/sangh supporters child sex ratio is quiet low.Women never matter to them except when they decide to marry a person from different religion on their own choice
    The high percentage of women in kerala is due to the longevity of life of women and reduced male average life expectancy(this reduced life expectancy too is few years more than gujarat and other states)due to excessive alcoholism and migration of men to other states for jobs.
    THe number of male children born will be more than women across the world but girl children have less fatal illnesses in early childhood and the sex ratio evens out

    The basic role of any government is to provide security to its ciizens who are alive,who are to be born etc.Its arrogance of the highest order to ignore selective abortions and doing nothing to prevent it inspite of stringent laws to punish the offenders because they happen to be the support base of sangh parivar.

    Reply
    1. sundakka Post author

      That post is satirical to the extent that Govt has a little role to play in improving CSR. Sure it has role to play in eradicating infanticide by increasing awareness, but convictions will not stop infanticide, education could but not necessarily. It us up to people to change. You can’t hold state responsible for actions of the community. I will not stoop low to the extent that only Sanghis kill girl child and Muslims / Tribals dont. That is politics without data. Where did the secular line go? ‘Hindus are not Girl killers’ like they say ‘Muslims are not terrorists’? The refusal to accept pseudo secularism(communalism) and pseudo feminism(sexism) has what has to lead to situation today where we are refusing to see real problem and happy with pointing fingers.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s